The Columbus Buckeyes were one of two new teams to entered the American Association, in the upstart league's second season. Managed by Horace Phillips, the Buckeyes struggled immensely in their first season, finishing sixth among eight teams with a record of 32-65.

The top hitter in Columbus was John Richmond with a . 283 average, while Pop Smith hit .

262 with a team best four home runs. On the mound Frank Mountain posted a record of 26-33, with a 3.

60 ERA, while Ed Dundon the first deaf player in the majors posted a record of 3-16, with a 4. 48 ERA.