1996 MLS Cup Champions
DC United

1997 MLS Cup Champions
DC United

1998 MLS Cup Champions
Chicago Fire

1999 MLS Cup Champions
DC United

2000 MLS Cup Champions
Kansas City Wizards

2001 MLS Cup Champions
San Jose Earthquakes

2002 MLS Cup Champions
L.A. Galaxy

2003 MLS Cup Champions
San Jose Earthquakes

2004 MLS Cup Champions
DC United

2005 MLS Cup Champions
L.A. Galaxy

2006 MLS Cup Champions
Houston Dynamo

2007 MLS Cup Champions
Houston Dynamo

2008 MLS Cup Champions
Columbus Crew

2009 MLS Cup Champions
Real Salt Lake

2010 MLS Cup Champions
Colorado Rapids

2011 MLS Cup Champions
L.A. Galaxy

2012 MLS Cup Champions
L.A. Galaxy

2013 MLS Cup Champions
Sporting Kansas City

2014 MLS Cup Champions
L.A. Galaxy

2015 MLS Cup Champions
Portland Timbers

2016 MLS Cup Champions
Seattle Sounders F.C.

2017 MLS Cup Champions
Toronto FC

2018 MLS Cup Champions
Atlanta United F.C.

2018 MLS Cup Champions
Seattle Sounders F.C.